AN ACT TO OUTLAW VOICE VOTING IN THE TENNESSEE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

RHB/2/19

Sponsored by Vivien Webster, Michelle Jiang of Baylor School

This legislation was filed in the Finance and Administration category

Presented as part of the YIG Volunteer 2024 conference

1 BE IT ENACTED BY THE TENNESSEE YMCA YOUTH IN GOVERNMENT
2
3 Section 1) Terms in this act shall be defined as follows:
4 a. Voice Vote: A style of voting in which the committee chair asks for “ayes” and “nays” and
5 determines whether a bill passes based on the volume of the responses.
6 b. Roll Call Vote: A style of voting in which the committee chair asks each House member
7 individually to vote “aye” or “nay”, recording the votes on a tally sheet.
8 c. Committee Chair: The leader of a House Committee, responsible for directing committee
9 sessions; the chair is picked by the Speaker of the House.
10 d. Speaker of the House: The presiding officer of the Tennessee House of Representatives
11 e. Show of Hands Vote: A style of voting where the chair calls for those in favor to raise their
12 hand, calls for those opposed to raise their hand, and tallies the results to determine the passage
13 of the bill.
14 f. Rising Vote: A style of voting, similar to the show of hands vote, in which those in favor and
15 those opposed stand when prompted to by the chair.
16
17 Section 2) Passage of new bills in the House of Representatives shall be decided exclusively via roll
18 call voting.
19 I. This is in direct compliance of Section 83, Subsection 10 from the “Permanent Rules of
20 Order” from Tennessee House of Representatives 111th General Assembly.
21 a. Section 83, subsection 10 states “All votes constituting final action on any bill or
22 resolution shall be by roll call vote.”
23 b. This rule has been disregarded on several occasions by the Tennessee House of
24 Representatives.
25
26 Section 3) An alternate form of voting to replace the voice vote on matters other than the passage
27 of a bill (i.e amendments) is a vote via a show of hands or rising vote.
28 I. Voting via showing of hands or rising maintains the efficiency of the vote, without the
29 subjectivity of the voice vote.
30
31 Section 4) Any committee chair found in noncompliance of this bill shall be subjected to expulsion.
32 I. As stated in Article II, section 12 of the Tennessee constitution, the House reserves the right
33 to “punish its members for disorderly behavior” with actions such as expulsion, censorship, fines,
34 or other reprimands.
35
36 Section 5) This act requires no funding.
37 Section 6) All laws or parts of laws in conflict with this act are hereby repealed.
38 Section 7) This act shall take effect on January 1, 2025.
39